Should You Attack or Spare Captain Aelfyr in Avowed?

In Avowed, the decision to attack or spare Captain Aelfyr during the "A Path to the Garden" quest presents a strategic dilemma. This guide analyzes the benefits of each choice.

Attacking Captain Aelfyr: The Optimal Choice

Attacking Aelfyr yields significant rewards, most notably the unique Death Knight Gloves. These gloves are particularly beneficial for defenders and elemental fighters, offering a 10% reduction in stamina cost while blocking and a 15% boost to frost damage.

The Death Knight Gloves & other rewards you get in Avowed for correctly killing Captain Aelfyr in Avowed during

Image Source: Obsidian Entertainment via The Escapist

Beyond the gloves, defeating Aelfyr grants access to additional loot, including:

A Garnet (Gem)
26 Silver Fenning coins
Exceptional Scale Armor (+0/3)
Exceptional Great Sword (+0/3)

This loot provides a substantial gear upgrade opportunity, especially for players who haven't prioritized equipment enhancements. Furthermore, you can loot the fallen Steel Garrote soldiers for extra items.

Sparing Captain Aelfyr: The Unrewarding Option

Choosing to spare Aelfyr offers no tangible rewards. The primary benefit is avoiding a challenging battle against Aelfyr and her Steel Garrote soldiers, which includes melee fighters and healing mages. This might be advantageous for under-leveled players who can adjust the game's difficulty. The impact on Giatta's disposition is minimal, resulting in only minor conversational differences.

Conclusion: Attack for Rewards

While sparing Aelfyr avoids a difficult fight, attacking her provides substantial rewards, including unique and powerful equipment. Therefore, attacking Captain Aelfyr is the strategically superior option in Avowed. This decision allows players to acquire valuable loot and enhance their character's capabilities.